Jeez, I should've read the above post before. Thanks for point it out for me GSP.gsp_ wrote:See posts above.DmDave wrote:Has anyone tried doing Norbert's gambit with Horizon ETF? Specifically I'm looking at HXS and HXS.U.
Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Just to let people know. I found a broker at TDDI who would do it on the phone (at online rate). My conclusion is that it is a total mixed bag - some follow the policy and refuse, others are happy to do it.
I will still get the account short enabled to simplify things.
I will still get the account short enabled to simplify things.
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
ask for their name and phone number, next time you need to perform a currency conversion, just call your buddy and avoid haggling with others repmarcharry wrote:Just to let people know. I found a broker at TDDI who would do it on the phone (at online rate). My conclusion is that it is a total mixed bag - some follow the policy and refuse, others are happy to do it.
I will still get the account short enabled to simplify things.
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Did a gambit today at TDDI non registered account. Used CM. For the first time I was able to do it without talking to a rep. The key(I think) was that I did the USD short sale first, and the US account needs to be short enabled, which it is. I still need to call them to journal the shares over. Finally, total success!!
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Not until you complete the journal.SQRT wrote:Finally, total success!!
The last time I did the gambit in a non registered account, TDDI back office lost or ignored my journalling request. I had to call them the second time to repeat the same request. Their system ended up charging me the margin interest in the short sub-account because the journal happened a few days after the settlement date. I had to call the third time to reverse the interest charge.
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
All of this is documented on finiki, and has been repeated many times in this thread. But congratulations!SQRT wrote:Did a gambit today at TDDI non registered account. Used CM. For the first time I was able to do it without talking to a rep. The key(I think) was that I did the USD short sale first, and the US account needs to be short enabled, which it is. I still need to call them to journal the shares over. Finally, total success!!
Do not call to ask for a journal until Monday (3 business days). If you do call early, it will not expedite it at all, and it may increase the level of frustration on your side. Patience is a virtue!
finiki, the Canadian financial wiki
“It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.” [Richard P. Feynman, Nobel prize winner]
“It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.” [Richard P. Feynman, Nobel prize winner]
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
I already called to journal. Now will have to cross my fingers. Not sure why it didn't work this well before, but happy it works now.adrian2 wrote:All of this is documented on finiki, and has been repeated many times in this thread. But congratulations!SQRT wrote:Did a gambit today at TDDI non registered account. Used CM. For the first time I was able to do it without talking to a rep. The key(I think) was that I did the USD short sale first, and the US account needs to be short enabled, which it is. I still need to call them to journal the shares over. Finally, total success!!
Do not call to ask for a journal until Monday (3 business days). If you do call early, it will not expedite it at all, and it may increase the level of frustration on your side. Patience is a virtue!
- ClosetIndexer
- Contributor
- Posts: 267
- Joined: 27 Feb 2012 02:20
- Location: Vancouver, BC
- Contact:
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
You're lucky you didn't get hassled. Many reps (at least as of a few months ago) will freak out when they see that you're long and short the same stock, not realizing that this is fine as long as the short came first. Once I even had one tell me that he was going to cancel one of the positions, leaving me with huge market exposure. Unsurprisingly that didn't actually happen, but still, it's easiest to just call them on settlement day and have them do the journal immediately.SQRT wrote:I already called to journal. Now will have to cross my fingers. Not sure why it didn't work this well before, but happy it works now.adrian2 wrote:All of this is documented on finiki, and has been repeated many times in this thread. But congratulations!SQRT wrote:Did a gambit today at TDDI non registered account. Used CM. For the first time I was able to do it without talking to a rep. The key(I think) was that I did the USD short sale first, and the US account needs to be short enabled, which it is. I still need to call them to journal the shares over. Finally, total success!!
Do not call to ask for a journal until Monday (3 business days). If you do call early, it will not expedite it at all, and it may increase the level of frustration on your side. Patience is a virtue!
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Thanks for the advice. No hassle when I called yesterday. Got a reference number for the journal transfer so I'm fairly confident it will happen. Will report back once it is done.ClosetIndexer wrote:
You're lucky you didn't get hassled. Many reps (at least as of a few months ago) will freak out when they see that you're long and short the same stock, not realizing that this is fine as long as the short came first. Once I even had one tell me that he was going to cancel one of the positions, leaving me with huge market exposure. Unsurprisingly that didn't actually happen, but still, it's easiest to just call them on settlement day and have them do the journal immediately.
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Everything worked as planned. Shares journaled as instructed, money received as expected. Yay!!!
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Shorting a stock that you're long on is perfectly fine in Canada. In fact, it's perfectly fine in the US too; you just don't get the benefit of the long-term capital gains rate when you sell.ClosetIndexer wrote:You're lucky you didn't get hassled. Many reps (at least as of a few months ago) will freak out when they see that you're long and short the same stock, not realizing that this is fine as long as the short came first. Once I even had one tell me that he was going to cancel one of the positions, leaving me with huge market exposure. Unsurprisingly that didn't actually happen, but still, it's easiest to just call them on settlement day and have them do the journal immediately.
- Bylo Selhi
- Veteran Contributor
- Posts: 29493
- Joined: 16 Feb 2005 10:36
- Location: Waterloo, ON
- Contact:
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
How is that relevant to an NG, whether going short or long the US asset?Rysto wrote:you just don't get the benefit of the long-term capital gains rate when you sell.
Sedulously eschew obfuscatory hyperverbosity and prolixity.
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
It's not. My point is, the only "problem" with shorting a stock that you are long in is that the IRS deems this "shorting against the box", and when you do it, you are deemed to have sold the stock that you are long in for tax purposes. "Shorting against the box" used to be a tactic to avoid US short-term capital gains taxes.Bylo Selhi wrote:How is that relevant to an NG, whether going short or long the US asset?Rysto wrote:you just don't get the benefit of the long-term capital gains rate when you sell.
For some reason some brokers have gotten the idea that shorting against the box is the worst investment sin imaginable, leading some to, for example, threaten to cancel a long or short position to prevent it
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Action Direct is simple.Buy on Toronto and sell on New York and click USA dollars on the sell. Not a complicated process.
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Hello gambiters,
I performed another large gambit at TDDI today. I used TD stock (as always) with market price for both the buy (CA) and sell (US) operation, here are the results:
XE.COM SPOT: 1.09753
Norbert's gambit Result: 1.09806
The difference represent just about 2 x 9.99$
The operation took less than 2min with about 10 second between the buy and the sell.
protip: if you find a gambit friendly rep, get their name+extension and call them back
I performed another large gambit at TDDI today. I used TD stock (as always) with market price for both the buy (CA) and sell (US) operation, here are the results:
XE.COM SPOT: 1.09753
Norbert's gambit Result: 1.09806
The difference represent just about 2 x 9.99$
The operation took less than 2min with about 10 second between the buy and the sell.
protip: if you find a gambit friendly rep, get their name+extension and call them back
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
I've performed norbert's gambit numerous times with tdw, but always within a registered account (rrsp).
Will be looking to perform shortly with an unregistered account. Are the operations the same? Anything to take into account?
Thanks!
Will be looking to perform shortly with an unregistered account. Are the operations the same? Anything to take into account?
Thanks!
- ClosetIndexer
- Contributor
- Posts: 267
- Joined: 27 Feb 2012 02:20
- Location: Vancouver, BC
- Contact:
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Unfortunately the process is not as smooth at TD in a non-registered account. The most foolproof way is to get your account set up for short selling. That way you can short on one side, then sell on the other, wait three days, and then call them to journal the shares over and flatten the position.Rooster wrote:I've performed norbert's gambit numerous times with tdw, but always within a registered account (rrsp).
Will be looking to perform shortly with an unregistered account. Are the operations the same? Anything to take into account?
Thanks!
Otherwise you'll have to call up a rep to journal the shares before you can sell, which can result in a delay with market exposure. (Personally if I didn't have the ability to short, I'd just use DLR and DLR.U, even though you give up a bit compared to using a small spread stock like TD.)
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Unless there are some costs that I am unaware of, exchanging money at a reasonable rate seems to be a lost business opportunity. Can it really cost that much to exchange currency in these days of lightening fast computer transactions? I can't figure out why there is no discount broker out there, particularly one of the smaller ones trying to grab business, that doesn't implement exchange fees that would be competitive to the gambit. Or possible even waive exchange fees for purchases and sales of US equities. I guess there must be a reason.
If life seems jolly rotten, then there's something you've forgotten -- and that's to laugh and smile and dance and sing. - Eric Idle
- Bylo Selhi
- Veteran Contributor
- Posts: 29493
- Joined: 16 Feb 2005 10:36
- Location: Waterloo, ON
- Contact:
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Why should they? It's a very lucrative business to charge 1% to 2% to convert dollars. (Like MF fees the percentage is small enough that most people won't notice it and even if they do it's not enough to get them to choose lower cost securities like ETFs.) Over millions of transactions this has to be a big money spinner for the brokers.
Consider a similar situation, the 2.5% vig that credit card companies charge on FX transactions. That has the same characteristics as brokerage FX vig, generates even more easy revenue and presumably should attract even more competition. And yet there's only one card company, Chase, that waives this fee and only on a few specialty cards. If the general public was generally aware of and truly incensed by this fee why haven't they abandoned main stream cards en masse for the likes of amazon.ca Visa?
Consider a similar situation, the 2.5% vig that credit card companies charge on FX transactions. That has the same characteristics as brokerage FX vig, generates even more easy revenue and presumably should attract even more competition. And yet there's only one card company, Chase, that waives this fee and only on a few specialty cards. If the general public was generally aware of and truly incensed by this fee why haven't they abandoned main stream cards en masse for the likes of amazon.ca Visa?
Sedulously eschew obfuscatory hyperverbosity and prolixity.
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Thank you. How long does it typically take to get the shares journaled and resellable on the US side?ClosetIndexer wrote:Unfortunately the process is not as smooth at TD in a non-registered account. The most foolproof way is to get your account set up for short selling. That way you can short on one side, then sell on the other, wait three days, and then call them to journal the shares over and flatten the position.Rooster wrote:I've performed norbert's gambit numerous times with tdw, but always within a registered account (rrsp).
Will be looking to perform shortly with an unregistered account. Are the operations the same? Anything to take into account?
Thanks!
Otherwise you'll have to call up a rep to journal the shares before you can sell, which can result in a delay with market exposure. (Personally if I didn't have the ability to short, I'd just use DLR and DLR.U, even though you give up a bit compared to using a small spread stock like TD.)
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Anyone have any notes on how to keep track of gambit transactions for accounting ?
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
I don't keep track of it at all. There really shouldn't be a taxable gain if you use the right FX rate. I guess if you delayed for a day or two you would have a gain or loss. Anybody else report any taxable event for a gambit?larry81 wrote:Anyone have any notes on how to keep track of gambit transactions for accounting ?
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
I'm using calendar year forex rates, so yes, in my case a gambit results in a capital gain or loss.SQRT wrote:I don't keep track of it at all. There really shouldn't be a taxable gain if you use the right FX rate. I guess if you delayed for a day or two you would have a gain or loss. Anybody else report any taxable event for a gambit?larry81 wrote:Anyone have any notes on how to keep track of gambit transactions for accounting ?
finiki, the Canadian financial wiki
“It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.” [Richard P. Feynman, Nobel prize winner]
“It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.” [Richard P. Feynman, Nobel prize winner]
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
That seems counter intuitive to me. Clearly, you did not actually have a gain or loss if you do the gambit right?adrian2 wrote:I'm using calendar year forex rates, so yes, in my case a gambit results in a capital gain or loss.SQRT wrote:I don't keep track of it at all. There really shouldn't be a taxable gain if you use the right FX rate. I guess if you delayed for a day or two you would have a gain or loss. Anybody else report any taxable event for a gambit?larry81 wrote:Anyone have any notes on how to keep track of gambit transactions for accounting ?
Re: Norbert's gambit - Can$ to US$ or vice versa
Say you buy today 100 shares of CM for USD10k, and you sell them for CAD10.8k. Since the forex used for the USD transaction is determined at year end, it may result in a capital gain or loss.SQRT wrote:That seems counter intuitive to me. Clearly, you did not actually have a gain or loss if you do the gambit right?adrian2 wrote:I'm using calendar year forex rates, so yes, in my case a gambit results in a capital gain or loss.
finiki, the Canadian financial wiki
“It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.” [Richard P. Feynman, Nobel prize winner]
“It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.” [Richard P. Feynman, Nobel prize winner]