In our case, the impact of hypothetically going from $500 to $1k deductible was not large. It was going from $1k to $2k that really made a difference.
Self Insurance Successful Experiences / Stories?
Re: Self Insurance Successful Experiences / Stories?
finiki, the Canadian financial wiki: a knowledge base of financial subjects written from a Canadian perspective
- IdOp
- Veteran Contributor
- Posts: 3873
- Joined: 16 Feb 2006 11:27
- Location: On the Pacific sea bed, 100 mi off the CA coast.
- Contact:
Re: Self Insurance Successful Experiences / Stories?
One of the factors restraining the amount of my deductible increase was that it was for a new car. I figured that with nervousness and/or unfamiliarity, maybe the odds of an accident would be higher than usual. So far so good fortunately.
Re: Self Insurance Successful Experiences / Stories?
I didn't realize you could do that. This raises the question of whether self-insurance within a group of similar-risk individuals is feasible and financially viable. I believe the Mennonites in our area do this for barns, houses, cars and farm equipment. Maybe there's a place for some small, new start-up self-insuring co-ops. It could start with cars and (possibly) develop into insurance for homes, without all the administrative and real estate overhead of the big companies. A $2,000 initial investment from a group of 20 people self-insuring, for example, would cover collision for one $40,000 vehicle. After four or five years (without a flurry of claims) the cushion would be comfortable.Quebec wrote:we have two cars insured. The older one is, disappointingly, only worth $3k on kijiji/LesPacs, so with the new $2k deductible, it did not make much sense to have accident coverage, and we only kept the $2M liability on that one.
"Why do I have to go to school? If I watch YouTube I'll know everything."
- Grandson #2
- Grandson #2
Re: Increasing the deductibles
YMMV, I guess.Quebec wrote: ↑19 Sep 2017 19:58 1. Home: we switched from comprehensive coverage to a slightly less comprehensive form, where there are stated limits on what value they will pay for your bike, your artwork, etc. What I really want to protect 100% of is the building. I don't own a $2k TV, or a $5k diamond ring, so the new limits on some types of contents make no difference to me. The insurance company also wanted to use a reconstruction value for the building that was way more than the approximate market price of the building AND the land combined. That made no sense (the land value being almost half the property value in our case; land does not burn), and after some discussion they agreed to use the same reconstruction value as the previous year (still too much, but who knows how much reconstruction would actually cost, so better be on the safe side here). Finally there was the increase in the deductible, which was the biggest factor.
I had a comprehensive and downgraded it to mid-range broad (the only difference was only specific perils in the latter).
I had a 1K deductible and bumped it to 2K.
Total savings was less than a hundred bucks per year.
This was CAA home insurance.
They had no line-item editing of limits as indicated above.
They had no option of increasing the deductible beyond 2K.
..hmm.. maybe they suck.
"A dividend is a dictate of management. A capital gain is a whim of the market."
Re: Increasing the deductibles
I would definitely call another insurer (or two) to inquire about higher deductibles. The competition might also have better rates in general, who knows. Shopping around (making sure to compare nearly identical policies) is still the number one tip when it comes to saving on home and auto insurance.
Good luck!
finiki, the Canadian financial wiki: a knowledge base of financial subjects written from a Canadian perspective
Re: Self Insurance Successful Experiences / Stories?
In Quebec the only mandatory auto insurance is 3rd party liability. Other provinces have different rules.